Brandy Alexander Recipe & The History Of The Brandy Alexander - The Nibble Webzine Of Food Adventures Brandy Alexander Recipe & The History Of The Brandy Alexander
 
 
 
 
THE NIBBLE BLOG: Products, Recipes & Trends In Specialty Foods


Also visit our main website, TheNibble.com.

Brandy Alexander Recipe & The History Of The Brandy Alexander

January 31st is National Brandy Alexander Day. We look at it as a transition out of Healthy Food Month at THE NIBBLE and a way to gird ourselves for Valentine’s Day carbs.

The creamy cocktail was often served as a nightcap.

It’s dangerously good—like a spiked milkshake—and you can have it as a dessert. We have served it with a small scoop of chocolate or vanilla ice cream in the center of the coupe.

Below:

> The history of the Brandy Alexander.

> Have fun with these recipe variations.

Elsewhere on The Nibble:

> The year’s 50+ cocktail and spirits holidays.

> What is Cognac and the different classifications of Cognac. Brandy uses similar age-based classifications with differences by category*.
 
 
BRANDY ALEXANDER HISTORY

According to the Classic Cocktail Club of Milan, Italy, the Brandy Alexander was created in 1922 in London, “at the time of” the wedding of Mary, Princess Royal and Countess of Harewood to Henry, Viscount Lascelles (later, 6th Earl of Harewood).

But this is cocktail legend. the Alexander was created in New York City, with the earliest-known printed recipe dating to 1916.

The cocktail is believed to have originated at Rector’s (est. 1899), a seafood restaurant in the New York theater district.

The bartender there, one Troy Alexander, created the eponymous concoction as a snowy white drink for a dinner celebrating the Phoebe Snow advertising campaign of the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad. That first Alexander contained clear gin—a white spirit instead of the brown brandy that was to come.

Not to be confused with the Baby Boomer singer Phoebe Snow (1950-2011) who was not yet around, this Phoebe was a fictitious advertising character, a Gibson Girl-type who debuted in 1903.

She was always clad in a snowy white dress to highlight the cleanliness of the railroad’s anthracite-coal-powered trains, a clean-burning variety of coal. The smokeless coal of railroad’s locomotives could never shed coal dust on that white dress!

While the cocktail went on to be well received by the public, the use of heavy cream was so uncommon at the time that critics boxed it in as a “lady’s cocktail,” an “ignorable drink” for men, in the days of the stiff Old Fashioned. But the critics didn’t kill off the drink.
 
 
Irony: Prohibition Saved The Alexander From Obscuity

Ironically, Prohibition saved the drink. The heavy cream and sugar were perfect for masking the harsh, chemical taste of illegally distilled “bathtub” gin.

Subsequently, bartenders began experimenting with Cognac or brandy. The richer, oaky profile of aged grape spirit harmonized with chocolate far better than the piney notes of gin. This brandy version was sometimes called the Alexander #2.

After the repeal of Prohibition, the Brandy Alexander became a popular after-dinner drink or nightcap. It appealed to a new demographic of social drinkers who didn’t enjoy the burn of straight whiskey or dry martinis. The drink began to enter popular culture through literature and film.

By the 1960s, the Brandy Alexander was firmly established and the original gin version was largely forgotten. It fit right into the 1960s cocktail culture, where rich, creamy drinks (like the Grasshopper, Pink Squirrel, and White Russian) were at thepeak of fashion.

By this time, the International Bartenders Association (IBA) had essentially codified the Brandy version as the Alexander.
 
 
And Now, The John Lennon/Brandy Alexander “Incident”

On March 12, 1974, Lennon attended a Smothers Brothers concert at The Troubadour nightclub in Hollywood with a fellow musician, Harry Nilsson. Nilsson introduced Lennon to the Brandy Alexander, which would become Lennon’s favorite cocktail (he loved heavy cream and poured it on his breakfast cornflakes).

But his first reaction that night was to call it a milkshake, and he continued to down shake after shake.

Not surprisingly, he became heavily intoxicated and, encouraged by Nilsson, began to relentlessly heckle the Smothers Brothers with profanities. The situation escalated until security intervened.

During the scuffle that followed, Lennon lost his signature round glasses, and he and Nilsson were ejected from the club. The next day, Lennon and Nilsson sent flowers and apologies and the Smothers Brothers graciously defended Lennon to the world press.

Ironically, the original milkshake was made with whiskey.
 
 
RECIPE: BRANDY ALEXANDER
 
If you choose to use Cognac instead of brandy, use a VS or at best, a VSOP*.

Ingredients Per Drink

  • 1-1/2 ounces brandy
  • 1 ounce dark crème de cacao†
  • 1 ounce half-and-half
  • 1/4 teaspoon grated nutmeg
  •  

    Brandy Alexander
    [1] A Brandy Alexander cocktail (photo courtesy Liquor.com | Gemini).

    Brandy Alexander With A Rolled Wafer Cookie Garnish
    [2] A rolled wafer cookie is a fun garnish (photo © Taste Of Home).

    Bottles Of Courvoisier VS and VSOP Cognac
    [3] Brandy is a broad term for a strong, distilled spirit made by fermenting and distilling fruit juice. Cognac is a grape brandy made in the Cognac region of France*. There are different classifications of Cognac. For a creamy mixed drink, use a VS or VSOP (photo © Deeliver | Unsplash).

    Gin Alexander Cocktail
    [4] The original Alexander, created to be snowy white, was made with gin. Here’s the recipe (photo © TexanErin).

    Brandy Alexander Milkshake
    [5] How about a Brandy Alexander milkshake? Here’s the recipe (photo © Bellyfull).

     
    Preparation

    1. Fill a shaker halfway with ice cubes.

    2. Add brandy, creme de cacao and half-and-half; shake well.

    3. Strain into a martini glass and garnish with grated nutmeg. Or, rim the glass with a mixture of nutmeg and sugar.
     
     
    HOW TO TWEAK THE BRANDY ALEXANDER

    Since it follows a simple equal-parts template (1:1:1 ratio of spirit, dark crème de cacao, and heavy cream), the Brandy Alexander is incredibly easy to revise.

  • Flavored Brandy. Brandy is made in different flavors, from an orange-flavored Cognac like Grand Marnier, to apple, apricot, blackberry, cherry, ginger, peach, raspberry, and more. The key is to use a flavor that goes well with the chocolate notes of crème de cacao.
  • Switch The Brandy. Alexander #1 uses gin instead of brandy for a brighter, more botanical, and less heavy drink. The Panama uses aged rum; the molasses and vanilla notes in the rum pair beautifully with the chocolate liqueur. The Bourbon Alexander uses a high-proof Bourbon for a smoky, oaky bite that cuts through the cream.
  • Change The Cream. Infuse the cream with Earl Grey tea leaves, cinnamon sticks, or fresh mintgo dairy-free with a can of coconut cream to create a “Mounds Bar” flavor profile.
  • Change The Crème de Cacao. Use a craft chocolate liqueur like Tempus Fugit Crème de Cacao for a less sweet, roasted cacao beans flavor; or replace half of the chocolate liqueur with hazelnut liqueur (like Frangelico) for a “Nutella” (amaretto almond liqueur is another option).
  • Freeze It. Throw the ingredients into a high-powered blender with a handful of ice for a Frozen Alexander.
  • Add Espresso. A half shot of fresh espresso creates a Mocha Alexander.
  • Make it a dessert. Add a scoop of chocolate or vanilla ice cream to a regular or Frozen Alexander served in a globe wine goblet or coupe glass, with an optional bit of whipped cream.
  •  
    Gin Alexander
    [6] This Gin Alexander is ready for dessert: It blends in some ice cream. Here’s the recipe (photo © Slipsmith Gin).

    ________________

    *Cognac is a strictly protected name, an Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée or AOC under French and international law. It assures the buyer of a specific grape brandy produced in the Cognac region of France. It must be made from specific white grapes (mostly Ugni Blanc) with specific distillation techniques: twice-distilled in copper pots, and aged in French oak for at least two years. “Brandy” can be made anywhere in the world, and from any fruit.

    This does not mean that other brandies are inferior to Cognac (although many are). Fine brandies from other regions can be more expressive than the blended, double-distilled nature of many Cognacs. Examples include:
    > Armagnac, often considered more rustic and robust due to single distillation and column stills (we like Bhakta Spirits and Darroze).
    > Calvados (Apple/Pear Brandy), with offering rich fruit flavors.
    >Spanish Brandy, a.k.a. Brandy de Jerez, aged in sherry casks (we like Torres 30 Jaime I and Cardenal Mendoza).
    >American Brandy: Check out Copper & Kings and Laird’s Apple Brandy (especially the 7½ and 12-year-old).

    The original Alexander recipe would have used white crème de cacao, for a snow white drink.

    Brandy Alexander With A Nutmeg Rim
    [7] Add a nutmeg rim, or mix nutmeg with sugar. Use a grater or Microplane to hand-grate nutmeg (photo © Taste Of Home).
     
     

    CHECK OUT WHAT’S HAPPENING ON OUR HOME PAGE, THENIBBLE.COM.

     
      

    Please follow and like us:
    Pin Share




    Comments are closed.

    The Nibble Webzine Of Food Adventures
    RSS
    Follow by Email


    © Copyright 2005-2026 Lifestyle Direct, Inc. All rights reserved. All images are copyrighted to their respective owners.